I was having a conversation about politics with a co-worker a
couple of months back and it turned to talks of political funding and
organization by religious establishments and I made some comments that
apparently distinguished Mormonism from Christianity. Although I said nothing
negative about the LDS faith, I distinguished the two faiths as different. This
co-worker happened to be LDS. And something he said struck me as kind of funny.
He said, “I don’t know why everyone always sets us apart from the label ‘Christian’.
We’re Christians too.”
Ever since he said that, I have been paying attention. It
seems there is a new trend going on in the LDS church today that holds that
Mormonism (the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints) is just another
denomination of Christianity. At face value it seems believable enough. Mormons
and Christians both believe that Jesus is the way to salvation. They believe that
He is the Son of God. They believe you are saved by grace through faith in
Jesus. They believe that the blessed hope in Christ and His gift of salvation
will one day land you in heaven, a very nice place where God lives. Beyond that,
they both come to your door and try to give you tracts or talk to you about
Jesus.
You might be thinking, ‘with all those similarities, how
could you say that they’re different?’ Well, let me tell you how the LDS church
fundamentally differs from the classical Christian faith. Christians and
Mormons use the same terminology, but they mean totally different things by
them. A succinct statement of their differences is this: They both believe in
God, but they’re not the same God. They both believe in Jesus, but they’re not
the same Jesus. They both believe that grace saves, but they’re not the same
grace. They both believe in heaven, but they’re not the same heaven.
The god of the LDS faith has no son. The term ‘sons of god’
simply means creations of god. Jesus is not the only begotten Son of God as
Christians believe Him to be. He is one of many. And he’s a created being, the
spirit brother of Satan (the devil). There is no trinity in LDS theology. In
fact, the only reason Jesus holds the position he does as savior of the world
is because he essentially raised his hand first when god asked who wanted to
die for the sins of mankind. Grace, according to the apostle Paul, is totally
unearned. He stated that if you could earn grace, it wasn’t grace, and Christ
died for nothing. LDS teaches that although grace is unearned, there are
different levels of grace you can attain by your actions, by “living pure” as I
have heard it called. Lastly, they both believe in heaven, but the LDS vision
of heaven is so entirely different from the classical Christian view, they
cannot be the same heaven at all. This last point may be secondary, but the
other three are absolute pillars of the Christian faith that cannot be
compromised. If Jesus Christ is not God Himself, then we have no means of being
redeemed and forgiven of our sins.
But let me tell you the most compelling reason that I think
this is kind of a misinformation campaign. If you think about it, you could be
a solid Bible believing Christian and elders Johnson and Duarte will still come
to your house, offer to give you a Book of Mormon, and then ask you to read it
and then pray and ask God if it’s true. And that’s the clincher. They don’t
believe you are truly saved unless you are Mormon. In fact, their founder, Mr.
Joseph Smith, when he founded the LDS church, received direct revelations from
Jesus and from an angel which told him that all of the protestant Christian
faiths were false, and even blasphemous. They were abominations. None of them
were pure. The Christian faith had been altered from its original beliefs and
intent so much so that none of the denominations could be trusted for
salvation. This is the reason that Joseph Smith started the Mormon Church,
exactly because Christianity as it was known (and is still known today) couldn't
cut it.
So if Joseph Smith, the founder of the church, thought all
protestant faiths were abominations to God (and Catholics were even worse), how could the Mormon faith be just
another denomination of the protestant faith? What does that say about the
Mormon faith? The idea of that is self-contradictory, self-defeating. I would even take it so far as to say that the attempt to equate the two is dishonest, and that was my
point to my co-worker. I tried to choose my words as carefully as I could so I
didn't offend him, I was hoping to just make him think. But if you run into
this issue with LDS members who say “We’re just another Christian denomination,
just like you,” remember that Joseph Smith sure didn't see it that way. He
would have even been offended by that notion.
You sound like an otherwise good person, but are misinformed about Mormonism.
ReplyDeleteBeyond that, the two most common, universally accepted definitions of the word “Christian”, are (1) someone who believes in the divinity of Jesus Christ and (2) someone who believes/follows the teachings of Jesus Christ. Mormons definitely fit those two definitions, so they are certainly Christians.
Brian, on the second point, I am absolutely inclined to agree with you. The Mormons I have met are some of the most upstanding and stand-outishly good people that I have known. I have a lot of experience with LDS church members, I have read the Book of Mormon, and I even work for a company that is owned and run by Mormons. I'm not bashing Mormons here. I'm merely trying to make a distinction that I think is legitimate.
DeleteOn the first point, what do you mean when you use the word "divine"? Your answer to that question makes all the difference in the world.